RESULTS - Tuesday 10 Aug 2021

[Dave Deacon]

EAST

Bovey Tracey                3-2         Stoke Gabriel & Torbay Police

Crediton United            1-1          Holsworthy

Plymouth Marjon         1-1        Dartmouth

 

WEST

Penryn Athletic            3-3         Wendron United

St Austell                      1-1          Godolphin Atlantic (Newquay)

[Dave Deacon]

4 out of 5 draws tonight!

[David Bray]

1 - 1 at Poltair, both sides guilty of squandering gilt edge chances.

[Footballlover442]

1-1 at poltair 

Lots of chances at both ends. Both sides lacking the clinical touch this evening. But a good game to watch very end to end especially in the 2nd half. Draw was probably a fair result although I imagine st austell will be the much less happy of the two sides this evening 

[RAPPO]

PENRYN  3      Reeve 9’  Rapsey 33’  Shaw 58’

WENDRON 3   Wheat 28’  Grange 29’  Palmer 68(P)’

ATT:  152

REF:  ROWAN CLARKE 6/10 - ok but got some big decisions wrong. 

TEMP: 17c  SUNNY

PENRYN —  1 ADAM ROBARTHAN;   5 BILLY WILLIAMS, 15 NICK BOASE, 3 RUSSELL MAY(c);   2JAKE SHAW, 12 FRASER HARRIS, 18, MORGAN VALLEJO, 8 ALEX HAYHOE, 6 BRADLEY LIEVERS;   10 JACK RAPSEY, 7 RYAN REEVE     SUBS) 4 ADAM WILLIAMS (RAPSEY 68’) 11 JAMES DANIEL (HARRIS 75’) 14 CONNOR POWELL (HAYHOE 86’)

Really entertaining game tonight at Kernick Road with a draw probably the fair result after a strong Penryn start and a strong Wendron finish. Made me smile seeing Billy Stone at right back and Reece Carroll at left back for Wendron and Jack up front against them for Penryn. Been watching these boys play together since they were u.11s!! Bless em, all 22 year old young men now! Seems like yesterday!! Quite scary really!! 😳 Penryn almost opened the scoring after 90 seconds when a miskick by visiting keeper Ethan Fearn saw Ryan Reeve return the ball with interest but Fearn redeemed himself saving with his outstretched foot. Wendron had a chance of their own after 6’ but failed to hit the target at the far post. 3 minutes later Reeve ran on to a ball over the top and shot across Fearn into the far corner to open the scoring. On 17’ a great defence splitting pass from Jack Rapsey sent Morgan Vallejo clear but his powerful strike came back off the base of the post. Wendron were also creating chances and a cut back ended with a weak shot on 25’. You felt if Penryn didn’t go 2-0 up it would come back to bite them and that’s exactly what happened after 28’ when Robarthan made a fine reflex stop from a Rory Jarvis volley but it fell to Lucas Potts who looped it back into the 6 yard box and it fell under the bar and bounced into the roof of the net with Cam Wheat claiming a touch after his challenge on Robarthan. The keeper struggled to get off the floor but you’ve seen them given on those over protected species the keeper but young ref Rowan Clarke waved away any protests and awarded the goal. 45 seconds later the evening suddenly got worse for Penryn as Wendron took a surprise lead after a break down the left saw Jacob Grange score with a good snap shot high into the net. To be fair Penryn didn’t bemoan their bad luck and came straight back when a Vallejo corner was cleverly flick headered across goal by Nick Boase and Rapsey produced a sharp turn and finish from close range for the equaliser. 3 minutes before the break Reeve crossed low to the far post but Bradley Leivers could only divert the ball agonisingly wide at full stretch. A minute later a Vallejo ball over the top saw Reeve outpace the defence before shooting just over. (HT 2-2)

Ten minutes into the 2nd half a headed clearance dropped to Rapsey and he volleyed inches over from 15 yards. 2 minutes later a deft chip from Jarvis saw Robarthan tip over the bar. The 58th minute saw Penryn back in front,a Vallejo corner was volleyed in at the far post by the excellent Jake Shaw despite the best efforts of full back Stone to keep it out. On the hour visiting captain Scott Palmer was booked for a foul on Vallejo 35 yards from goal and Rapsey’s knuckle ball free kick cleared the wall but ended up in the grateful arms of Fearn. Wendron were pushing for a leveller and a good low shot was turned around the post by Robarthan on 65’. 2 minutes later the keeper misjudged a through ball skidding past him for Wheat to pounce and run on to and Robarthan fouled him from behind for a penalty. Thought a yellow card and a penalty would have sufficed with Wheat out on the edge of the area and going away from goal but the ref pulled out a straight red card which will see the keeper banned for 3 games!! Standing with Deacs and one of the county’s most respected and likeable referees when I was a player Gerald Searle and we all agreed, definitely a pen but a sending off very harsh with the keeper looking at a 3 game ban for that!! The hosts manager Harry Pope put Boase in goal, took striker Rapsey off, and Adam Williams on to replace the centre half, and captain Scott Palmer made no mistake smashing his spot kick into the corner of the net despite Boase diving the right way. Not surprisingly the last 20 minutes belonged to Wendron they shot wide when well placed on 80’, just couldn’t get the final touch to a great cross across the face of goal on 83’ before the now lone striker Reeve raced clear over the top after a rare Penryn break after 86’ and was scythed down in the area by big centre half Lee Padgeth. A more stonewall penalty you’ll never see but even though the linesman gave the foul from his perfect viewpoint the ref waved away all appeals from 30 yards away to the amazement of everyone within 50 yards of it!!! Only he will know why he didn’t give it!? He yellow carded Jack Stocker in the injury time to make it the 4th of the evening in a game played in great spirits between the two teams before some stout defending from the hosts led by superb skipper Russell May held out the now rampant Wendron until he blew his full time whistle in the 96th minute. Good evenings entertainment for the healthy crowd of 152 in attendance and both teams first point of the season on the board after both suffered opening day defeats. Good game of football 👍👏🏼⚽️

 

[Cornish Dave]

Cracking game between penryn and wendron. Finished 3-3 lots of enjoyable football. Good crowd and well officiated 👏

 

[bighairydave]

6 hours ago, RAPPO said:

PENRYN  3      Reeve 9’  Rapsey 33’  Shaw 58’

WENDRON 3   Wheat 28’  Grange 29’  Palmer 68(P)’

ATT:  152

REF:  ROWAN CLARKE 6/10 - ok but got some big decisions wrong. 

TEMP: 17c  SUNNY

PENRYN —  1 ADAM ROBARTHAN;   5 BILLY WILLIAMS, 15 NICK BOASE, 3 RUSSELL MAY(c);   2JAKE SHAW, 12 FRASER HARRIS, 18, MORGAN VALLEJO, 8 ALEX HAYHOE, 6 BRADLEY LIEVERS;   10 JACK RAPSEY, 7 RYAN REEVE     SUBS) 4 ADAM WILLIAMS (RAPSEY 68’) 11 JAMES DANIEL (HARRIS 75’) 14 CONNOR POWELL (HAYHOE 86’)

Really entertaining game tonight at Kernick Road with a draw probably the fair result after a strong Penryn start and a strong Wendron finish. Made me smile seeing Billy Stone at right back and Reece Carroll at left back for Wendron and Jack up front against them for Penryn. Been watching these boys play together since they were u.11s!! Bless em, all 22 year old young men now! Seems like yesterday!! Quite scary really!! 😳 Penryn almost opened the scoring after 90 seconds when a miskick by visiting keeper Ethan Fearn saw Ryan Reeve return the ball with interest but Fearn redeemed himself saving with his outstretched foot. Wendron had a chance of their own after 6’ but failed to hit the target at the far post. 3 minutes later Reeve ran on to a ball over the top and shot across Fearn into the far corner to open the scoring. On 17’ a great defence splitting pass from Jack Rapsey sent Morgan Vallejo clear but his powerful strike came back off the base of the post. Wendron were also creating chances and a cut back ended with a weak shot on 25’. You felt if Penryn didn’t go 2-0 up it would come back to bite them and that’s exactly what happened after 28’ when Robarthan made a fine reflex stop from a Rory Jarvis volley but it fell to Lucas Potts who looped it back into the 6 yard box and it fell under the bar and bounced into the roof of the net with Cam Wheat claiming a touch after his challenge on Robarthan. The keeper struggled to get off the floor but you’ve seen them given on those over protected species the keeper but young ref Rowan Clarke waved away any protests and awarded the goal. 45 seconds later the evening suddenly got worse for Penryn as Wendron took a surprise lead after a break down the left saw Jacob Grange score with a good snap shot high into the net. To be fair Penryn didn’t bemoan their bad luck and came straight back when a Vallejo corner was cleverly flick headered across goal by Nick Boase and Rapsey produced a sharp turn and finish from close range for the equaliser. 3 minutes before the break Reeve crossed low to the far post but Leivers could only divert the ball agonisingly wide at full stretch. A minute later a Vallejo ball over the top saw Reeve outpace the defence before shooting just over. (HT 2-2)

Ten minutes into the 2nd half a headed clearance dropped to Rapsey and he volleyed inches over from 15 yards. 2 minutes later a deft chip from Jarvis saw Robarthan tip over the bar. The 58th minute saw Penryn back in front,a Vallejo corner was volleyed in at the far post by the excellent Jake Shaw despite the best efforts of full back Stone to keep it out. On the hour visiting captain Scott Palmer was booked for a foul on Vallejo 35 yards from goal and Rapsey’s knuckle ball free kick cleared the wall but ended up in the grateful arms of Fearn. Wendron were pushing for a leveller and a good low shot was turned around the post by Robarthan on 65’. 2 minutes later the keeper misjudged a through ball skidding past him for Wheat to pounce and run on to and Robarthan fouled him from behind for a penalty. Thought a yellow card and a penalty would have sufficed with Wheat out on the edge of the area and going away from goal but the ref pulled out a straight red card which will see the keeper banned for 3 games!! Standing with Deacs and one of the county’s most respected and likeable referees when I was a player Gerald Searle and we all agreed, definitely a pen but a sending off very harsh with the keeper looking at a 3 game ban for that!! The hosts manager Harry Pope put Boase in goal, took striker Rapsey off, and Adam Williams on to replace the centre half, and captain Scott Palmer made no mistake smashing his spot kick into the corner of the net despite Boase diving the right way. Not surprisingly the last 20 minutes belonged to Wendron they shot wide when well placed on 80’, just couldn’t get the final touch to a great cross across the face of goal on 83’ before the now lone striker Reeve raced clear over the top after a rare Penryn break after 86’ and was scythed down in the area by big centre half Lee Padgeth. A more stonewall penalty you’ll never see but even though the linesman gave the foul from his perfect viewpoint the ref waved away all appeals from 30 yards away to the amazement of everyone within 50 yards of it!!! Only he will know why he didn’t give it!? He yellow carded Jack Stocker in the injury time to make it the 4th of the evening in a game played in great spirits between the two teams before some stout defending from the hosts led by superb skipper Russell May held out the now rampant Wendron until he blew his full time whistle in the 96th minute. Good evenings entertainment for the healthy crowd of 152 in attendance and both teams first point of the season on the board after both suffered opening day defeats. Good game of football 👍👏🏼⚽️

 

Only a 1 game ban! From next Tuesday.

[RAPPO]

Good news for the young man, thanks Hairydave 👍⚽️

 

[St Darren]

3 hours ago, Cornish Dave said:

Cracking game between penryn and wendron. Finished 3-3 lots of enjoyable football. Good crowd and well officiated 👏

 

Looking at the goal, it's a wonder how on earth it wasn't disallowed!! 

[SCFC]

9 hours ago, RAPPO said:

PENRYN  3      Reeve 9’  Rapsey 33’  Shaw 58’

WENDRON 3   Wheat 28’  Grange 29’  Palmer 68(P)’

ATT:  152

REF:  ROWAN CLARKE 6/10 - ok but got some big decisions wrong. 

TEMP: 17c  SUNNY

PENRYN —  1 ADAM ROBARTHAN;   5 BILLY WILLIAMS, 15 NICK BOASE, 3 RUSSELL MAY(c);   2JAKE SHAW, 12 FRASER HARRIS, 18, MORGAN VALLEJO, 8 ALEX HAYHOE, 6 BRADLEY LIEVERS;   10 JACK RAPSEY, 7 RYAN REEVE     SUBS) 4 ADAM WILLIAMS (RAPSEY 68’) 11 JAMES DANIEL (HARRIS 75’) 14 CONNOR POWELL (HAYHOE 86’)

Really entertaining game tonight at Kernick Road with a draw probably the fair result after a strong Penryn start and a strong Wendron finish. Made me smile seeing Billy Stone at right back and Reece Carroll at left back for Wendron and Jack up front against them for Penryn. Been watching these boys play together since they were u.11s!! Bless em, all 22 year old young men now! Seems like yesterday!! Quite scary really!! 😳 Penryn almost opened the scoring after 90 seconds when a miskick by visiting keeper Ethan Fearn saw Ryan Reeve return the ball with interest but Fearn redeemed himself saving with his outstretched foot. Wendron had a chance of their own after 6’ but failed to hit the target at the far post. 3 minutes later Reeve ran on to a ball over the top and shot across Fearn into the far corner to open the scoring. On 17’ a great defence splitting pass from Jack Rapsey sent Morgan Vallejo clear but his powerful strike came back off the base of the post. Wendron were also creating chances and a cut back ended with a weak shot on 25’. You felt if Penryn didn’t go 2-0 up it would come back to bite them and that’s exactly what happened after 28’ when Robarthan made a fine reflex stop from a Rory Jarvis volley but it fell to Lucas Potts who looped it back into the 6 yard box and it fell under the bar and bounced into the roof of the net with Cam Wheat claiming a touch after his challenge on Robarthan. The keeper struggled to get off the floor but you’ve seen them given on those over protected species the keeper but young ref Rowan Clarke waved away any protests and awarded the goal. 45 seconds later the evening suddenly got worse for Penryn as Wendron took a surprise lead after a break down the left saw Jacob Grange score with a good snap shot high into the net. To be fair Penryn didn’t bemoan their bad luck and came straight back when a Vallejo corner was cleverly flick headered across goal by Nick Boase and Rapsey produced a sharp turn and finish from close range for the equaliser. 3 minutes before the break Reeve crossed low to the far post but Bradley Leivers could only divert the ball agonisingly wide at full stretch. A minute later a Vallejo ball over the top saw Reeve outpace the defence before shooting just over. (HT 2-2)

Ten minutes into the 2nd half a headed clearance dropped to Rapsey and he volleyed inches over from 15 yards. 2 minutes later a deft chip from Jarvis saw Robarthan tip over the bar. The 58th minute saw Penryn back in front,a Vallejo corner was volleyed in at the far post by the excellent Jake Shaw despite the best efforts of full back Stone to keep it out. On the hour visiting captain Scott Palmer was booked for a foul on Vallejo 35 yards from goal and Rapsey’s knuckle ball free kick cleared the wall but ended up in the grateful arms of Fearn. Wendron were pushing for a leveller and a good low shot was turned around the post by Robarthan on 65’. 2 minutes later the keeper misjudged a through ball skidding past him for Wheat to pounce and run on to and Robarthan fouled him from behind for a penalty. Thought a yellow card and a penalty would have sufficed with Wheat out on the edge of the area and going away from goal but the ref pulled out a straight red card which will see the keeper banned for 3 games!! Standing with Deacs and one of the county’s most respected and likeable referees when I was a player Gerald Searle and we all agreed, definitely a pen but a sending off very harsh with the keeper looking at a 3 game ban for that!! The hosts manager Harry Pope put Boase in goal, took striker Rapsey off, and Adam Williams on to replace the centre half, and captain Scott Palmer made no mistake smashing his spot kick into the corner of the net despite Boase diving the right way. Not surprisingly the last 20 minutes belonged to Wendron they shot wide when well placed on 80’, just couldn’t get the final touch to a great cross across the face of goal on 83’ before the now lone striker Reeve raced clear over the top after a rare Penryn break after 86’ and was scythed down in the area by big centre half Lee Padgeth. A more stonewall penalty you’ll never see but even though the linesman gave the foul from his perfect viewpoint the ref waved away all appeals from 30 yards away to the amazement of everyone within 50 yards of it!!! Only he will know why he didn’t give it!? He yellow carded Jack Stocker in the injury time to make it the 4th of the evening in a game played in great spirits between the two teams before some stout defending from the hosts led by superb skipper Russell May held out the now rampant Wendron until he blew his full time whistle in the 96th minute. Good evenings entertainment for the healthy crowd of 152 in attendance and both teams first point of the season on the board after both suffered opening day defeats. Good game of football 👍👏🏼⚽️

 

cracking breakdown as always Rappo, always enjoy the depth of your analysis and the added personal touches that get included. Rather enjoyable to read rather than the standard "goal scored by Reeves 1-0", gives people who werent watching a real understanding of how the game went.

 

I also took in the game, very entertaining game, cant argue when you've seen 6 goals. Penryn maybe feel a bit hard done by and had the better chances but Wendron would feel they were equally as dangerous.

 

With the referee, 3 big calls in the game, of which I personally felt he got 2/3 correct. The first one with Cam on the goalkeeper, as we always see, its usually a given the keeper gets the foul in that scenario, but I was delighted to see the goal was given (confirmed having watched Matt Friday's video highlights on twitter), the keeper was weak, a fair and honest challenge, no foul at all. Certainly wouldnt be given if it was two players in the centre circle so I can never understand why keepers are given dispensation. A decision I thought was correct, but given the precedent set by most ref's to blow up for any challenge with a goalkeeper, i can understand Penryn's disappointment.

The red card for the keeper I personally felt was spot on, although understandably harsh. Letter of the law says the opponent has to make a genuine attempt to play the ball in order to avoid a sending off in those circumstances. Having missed the ball, Cam was in down the side, and the keeper has made a desperate attempt to take him out (no chance of winning the ball) and so the ref had no real option. Cam subsequently missed the strike on goal which again, can see why Penryn are disappointed.

That being said, the foul on Reeve late on, absolute stonewall and somehow has been missed. Linesman had waived for a foul and the ref decided to ignore. Can only imagine what he thinks hes seen there. Does beg the question as to whats the point in having a linesman if they arent going to be used?

 

Cracking game of football on the whole, but I'm sure Penryn will certainly feel the game was influenced by the ref in this case

 

 

[WendronOfficial]

1 hour ago, SCFC said:

cracking breakdown as always Rappo, always enjoy the depth of your analysis and the added personal touches that get included. Rather enjoyable to read rather than the standard "goal scored by Reeves 1-0", gives people who werent watching a real understanding of how the game went.

 

I also took in the game, very entertaining game, cant argue when you've seen 6 goals. Penryn maybe feel a bit hard done by and had the better chances but Wendron would feel they were equally as dangerous.

 

With the referee, 3 big calls in the game, of which I personally felt he got 2/3 correct. The first one with Cam on the goalkeeper, as we always see, its usually a given the keeper gets the foul in that scenario, but I was delighted to see the goal was given (confirmed having watched Matt Friday's video highlights on twitter), the keeper was weak, a fair and honest challenge, no foul at all. Certainly wouldnt be given if it was two players in the centre circle so I can never understand why keepers are given dispensation. A decision I thought was correct, but given the precedent set by most ref's to blow up for any challenge with a goalkeeper, i can understand Penryn's disappointment.

The red card for the keeper I personally felt was spot on, although understandably harsh. Letter of the law says the opponent has to make a genuine attempt to play the ball in order to avoid a sending off in those circumstances. Having missed the ball, Cam was in down the side, and the keeper has made a desperate attempt to take him out (no chance of winning the ball) and so the ref had no real option. Cam subsequently missed the strike on goal which again, can see why Penryn are disappointed.

That being said, the foul on Reeve late on, absolute stonewall and somehow has been missed. Linesman had waived for a foul and the ref decided to ignore. Can only imagine what he thinks hes seen there. Does beg the question as to whats the point in having a linesman if they arent going to be used?

 

Cracking game of football on the whole, but I'm sure Penryn will certainly feel the game was influenced by the ref in this case

 

 

Can’t disagree too much. An entertaining game, not heaps of quality but it had its moments and plenty of heart. 
With my claret and blue tinted glasses, our first goal was well summarised above. The pen and red were clear, I think it would’ve been a red card anywhere on the pitch; it was late, reckless, dangerous - he raked his studs down the back of Cam’s ankles. 
As for Penryn’s penalty shout, from my viewpoint the ball nicked our defender’s 4th stud down on the right side of his left boot... 
 

I think it was one of those games where both sides felt that they could’ve and should’ve won, both created some great chances - but at the same time happy to come away with the point.

Good crowd too, good to have Penryn in the league. 
Huge shout out  to @TheolderIgetthebetterIwas as well - cracking playing surface, full credit to you. 

[Cornish Dave]

5 hours ago, St Darren said:

Looking at the goal, it's a wonder how on earth it wasn't disallowed!! 

Which goal? Are you talking about the one where the goalie fell over? 

[RAPPO]

Yeah agree with you SCFC having watched the incidents back! Thanks to Matt for his excellent coverage of it! Still can’t believe the pen wasn’t given, spoke to bout a dozen people on the way out Penryn and Wendron and no one could believe it wasn’t given!! Not had much luck with refs first 2 games!! One gave a non existent pen on Saturday that even the Launceston players were laughing at and then one of the most stonewall penalties I’ve ever seen not given even though the Lino right next to it gave the foul!!! Thought it was a bit disrespectful he didn’t even hear his point of view. 🤔😳⚽️ But totally agree, the other two decisions were in hindsight, probably correct and well explained by yourself. Adam didn’t get off the ground and Cams challenge looked fine, just that 8/10 times it would be given as a foul by most refs who over protect the keeper! Reminded me of Shilton & Maradona that time!! 😂 Letter of the law then maybe the double whammy of penalty and red card thought was harsh but fair enough! 🤔 Draw probably fair result anyway over the 90 minutes. Nice club Wendron, hope both clubs have a good season 👍👏🏼⚽️

[Informed]

Makes a change for Penryn to not get everything their own like last few seasons. 

[St Darren]

4 hours ago, Cornish Dave said:

Which goal? Are you talking about the one where the goalie fell over? 

He didn't fall over did he? The striker looked to make no attempt for the ball, I think 9 out 10 times that's given a foul on the keeper. 

But I do agree that keepers are over protected and should be stronger in that situation anyway 

[100%cornish]

 Went up Mt Wise saw a brilliant game between Newquay 3 - St Blazey 3 this game had the lot , Blazey went in front from Mark Gusterson then Newquay got a soft pen which Cam Turner scored from ,Chri RESKI had to go off injured and was replaced by Kenny ,St Blazey went 2-1  up through Jed Smale and Ross Fallens equalised for Newquay score 2-2 half time where Newquay had enough chances to go in front but poor finishing and Jack Bray evans blockbuster which rattled the bar .2nd half and Blazey lost ther goalie Jason Chapman to injury and Will tinsley went in goal .Newquay went in front from Jack Bray EVANS and most people thought that was that Mark Gusterson equalised with a shot and a big deflection but it was still not over Cam Turner was sin binned then the ref who had  a shocker gave Blazey a pen when it should of been  Newquay free kick but justice was done when goalie Harry Ashton made a brilliant save and the game ended 3-3 .It was good to see Ollie Brockenshire and Mark Goldsworthy there and i took there photo with Smokie but dont know if its any good .This was the worst display of refereeing and linesman for a long time they where giving corners  when they should of been throw ins and giving soft pens 1 was a joke should of been a free kick to NEWQUAY thue officials where poor . it was nice see OLLIE BROCKENSHIRE AND MARK GOLDSWORTHY there and i took there photos with Smokie but dont know if they will come out .Ok mom for Newquay Fallens and for St Blazey Martin Giles . Ok this is my opinion so if anyone wants to criticise me go ahead i dont give  a shit .I will also let Rappo write War and PEACE a great write up as well but when i did a long write up i was had a go at well RAPPO is  a football legend and im a GRUMPY OLD CORNISHMAN with a poor excuse of a dog .Anyone who thought the officials had a good game tonight do need to go to Specsavers and most people i think will agree with me .So there you go A real advert for local footy thats why we love it 

[RAPPO]

Keep the reports coming Steve! I only do them cos I know some people can’t get to the games and like to know what’s going on. Not everyone will agree with what we write but at least we’ve made the effort to keep people informed that are interested to the best of our opinion! No such thing as a good or bad report as far as I’m concerned mate 👍👏🏼⚽️ You’ve told us what happened at Newquay tonight and it’s much appreciated by many of us. All the best to you and my old mate Smokie bud 👍⚽️

[St Darren]

It's good to read match reports, nice to read different opinions on a game. Can I ask one small favour though, that you can press snter/return on your keyboard to break the report up as it is then a lot easier to read. 

RAPPO, I just seen the video of the penalty incident in the penryn game, haha, how on earth that wasn't given I'll never know, the Wendron player no where near the ball. Was that you in the back ground as well? 

[bighairydave]

2 hours ago, St Darren said:

It's good to read match reports, nice to read different opinions on a game. Can I ask one small favour though, that you can press snter/return on your keyboard to break the report up as it is then a lot easier to read. 

RAPPO, I just seen the video of the penalty incident in the penryn game, haha, how on earth that wasn't given I'll never know, the Wendron player no where near the ball. Was that you in the back ground as well? 

 

[Cornish Dave]

10 hours ago, St Darren said:

He didn't fall over did he? The striker looked to make no attempt for the ball, I think 9 out 10 times that's given a foul on the keeper. 

But I do agree that keepers are over protected and should be stronger in that situation anyway 

It wasn’t a foul though the goalie had a stinker and tried the claim a cheap foul. Just like the red card it was last man no arguments 

[Outsider]

9 hours ago, 100%cornish said:

 Went up Mt Wise saw a brilliant game between Newquay 3 - St Blazey 3 this game had the lot , Blazey went in front from Mark Gusterson then Newquay got a soft pen which Cam Turner scored from ,Chri RESKI had to go off injured and was replaced by Kenny ,St Blazey went 2-1  up through Jed Smale and Ross Fallens equalised for Newquay score 2-2 half time where Newquay had enough chances to go in front but poor finishing and Jack Bray evans blockbuster which rattled the bar .2nd half and Blazey lost ther goalie Jason Chapman to injury and Will tinsley went in goal .Newquay went in front from Jack Bray EVANS and most people thought that was that Mark Gusterson equalised with a shot and a big deflection but it was still not over Cam Turner was sin binned then the ref who had  a shocker gave Blazey a pen when it should of been  Newquay free kick but justice was done when goalie Harry Ashton made a brilliant save and the game ended 3-3 .It was good to see Ollie Brockenshire and Mark Goldsworthy there and i took there photo with Smokie but dont know if its any good .This was the worst display of refereeing and linesman for a long time they where giving corners  when they should of been throw ins and giving soft pens 1 was a joke should of been a free kick to NEWQUAY thue officials where poor . it was nice see OLLIE BROCKENSHIRE AND MARK GOLDSWORTHY there and i took there photos with Smokie but dont know if they will come out .Ok mom for Newquay Fallens and for St Blazey Martin Giles . Ok this is my opinion so if anyone wants to criticise me go ahead i dont give  a shit .I will also let Rappo write War and PEACE a great write up as well but when i did a long write up i was had a go at well RAPPO is  a football legend and im a GRUMPY OLD CORNISHMAN with a poor excuse of a dog .Anyone who thought the officials had a good game tonight do need to go to Specsavers and most people i think will agree with me .So there you go A real advert for local footy thats why we love it 

 I look forward to reading your reports, 100%. Keep up the good work.

[FootballChat]

1 hour ago, Cornish Dave said:

It wasn’t a foul though the goalie had a stinker and tried the claim a cheap foul. Just like the red card it was last man no arguments 

Think the red is harsh, isn’t double jeopardy a thing now if it’s in the box? 
 

The pen at the end on Reeves is a joke, the lino gives it, is right in front of him and the ref gives nothing! Appalling.

 

No arguements from me about the goal though, Adam will be a bit embarased watching that back.

[SCFC]

1 hour ago, bighairydave said:

 

Always great to have some footage of the game. Clears up most arguments straight away. Have re watched them again, and still cant believe that foul at the end was not given as a penalty. Linesman flagged but could've done more IMO, flagged briefly and then immediately put it down. If he was certain, i feel he could have been more assertive.

Really enjoyed watching @RAPPO appealing for the penalty, the same off the field as he was on it  

[justanopinion]

Yes, agreed the young lino needs to do more. Clubs are paying £140 this season for THREE officials. The least the Ref could do was ask the lino for his opinion and reason for flagging.

 

[Martin Eddy]

30 minutes ago, SCFC said:

Always great to have some footage of the game. Clears up most arguments straight away. Have re watched them again, and still cant believe that foul at the end was not given as a penalty. Linesman flagged but could've done more IMO, flagged briefly and then immediately put it down. If he was certain, i feel he could have been more assertive.

Really enjoyed watching @RAPPO appealing for the penalty, the same off the field as he was on it  

Trouble is SCFC as an assistant you are there to support the referee who is in charge of the game. Have been told this on many occasions when not agreeing with a desicion.

[justanopinion]

It was pretty obvious that the Ref felt he did not need any support. Might as well run with club linos and save £80.

[FootballChat]

44 minutes ago, SCFC said:

Always great to have some footage of the game. Clears up most arguments straight away. Have re watched them again, and still cant believe that foul at the end was not given as a penalty. Linesman flagged but could've done more IMO, flagged briefly and then immediately put it down. If he was certain, i feel he could have been more assertive.

Really enjoyed watching @RAPPO appealing for the penalty, the same off the field as he was on it  

Harsh to pin the blame on the lino here.

 

They’ll have had a chat before the game about what the reff wants and ultimately the reff is in charge.

ive run the line in the past the help a few sides out and the reff almost always says ‘leave the free kicks and pens to me’

If he’s saying no then the lino hasn’t really got a choice but to put his flag down. 
 

I think they also pick which lino is more senior and they go the dugout side so this young lad would be the least experienced of all 3. Clear that the reff should of had a chat with him at least though

[SCFC]

47 minutes ago, Postman Pat said:

Trouble is SCFC as an assistant you are there to support the referee who is in charge of the game. Have been told this on many occasions when not agreeing with a desicion.

 

32 minutes ago, FootballChat said:

Harsh to pin the blame on the lino here.

 

They’ll have had a chat before the game about what the reff wants and ultimately the reff is in charge.

ive run the line in the past the help a few sides out and the reff almost always says ‘leave the free kicks and pens to me’

If he’s saying no then the lino hasn’t really got a choice but to put his flag down. 
 

I think they also pick which lino is more senior and they go the dugout side so this young lad would be the least experienced of all 3. Clear that the reff should of had a chat with him at least though

totally agree with you both. I wouldn't pin it on the lino, just thought he could have been a bit more assertive. Even if the ref has told him to leave free kicks etc to him, for the benefit of the game, if you 100% believe he is wrong, would you not want to help? maybe thats just my personal opinion.

A chat at least would have been good, would at least help us spectators out, rather than it appearing the ref has given the decision himself from miles away.

 

It does the beg the question, whats the point in having paid linesman if they arent going to be used? 

[Ian Pethick]

12 hours ago, 100%cornish said:

 Went up Mt Wise saw a brilliant game between Newquay 3 - St Blazey 3 this game had the lot , Blazey went in front from Mark Gusterson then Newquay got a soft pen which Cam Turner scored from ,Chri RESKI had to go off injured and was replaced by Kenny ,St Blazey went 2-1  up through Jed Smale and Ross Fallens equalised for Newquay score 2-2 half time where Newquay had enough chances to go in front but poor finishing and Jack Bray evans blockbuster which rattled the bar .2nd half and Blazey lost ther goalie Jason Chapman to injury and Will tinsley went in goal .Newquay went in front from Jack Bray EVANS and most people thought that was that Mark Gusterson equalised with a shot and a big deflection but it was still not over Cam Turner was sin binned then the ref who had  a shocker gave Blazey a pen when it should of been  Newquay free kick but justice was done when goalie Harry Ashton made a brilliant save and the game ended 3-3 .It was good to see Ollie Brockenshire and Mark Goldsworthy there and i took there photo with Smokie but dont know if its any good .This was the worst display of refereeing and linesman for a long time they where giving corners  when they should of been throw ins and giving soft pens 1 was a joke should of been a free kick to NEWQUAY thue officials where poor . it was nice see OLLIE BROCKENSHIRE AND MARK GOLDSWORTHY there and i took there photos with Smokie but dont know if they will come out .Ok mom for Newquay Fallens and for St Blazey Martin Giles . Ok this is my opinion so if anyone wants to criticise me go ahead i dont give  a shit .I will also let Rappo write War and PEACE a great write up as well but when i did a long write up i was had a go at well RAPPO is  a football legend and im a GRUMPY OLD CORNISHMAN with a poor excuse of a dog .Anyone who thought the officials had a good game tonight do need to go to Specsavers and most people i think will agree with me .So there you go A real advert for local footy thats why we love it 

Love your reports and thoughts 100%. Opinions are a personal thing, and we each have our own and (as long as they're not offensive) it's not a problem. Everybody will see the game and what happened within it differently, and that is one of the great things about football.

[Guest]

Interesting footage to say the least, but, the man in black`s decision is final even if he may have got one or two wrong 🤔😮😏🤣

[100%cornish]

Sorry about not breaking my sentences up but my laptop is on its last legs and teh keys stick , Love your reports look forward to reading them when you do them on Newquay and the G when Penryn come to town and Smokie will enjoy seeing you like he does . In the Newquay match last night when Blazey had a pen right at the end i wonder if the Blazey player Gusterson missed on purpose because he knew it wasnt a pen the Blazey player had his arms arms around Phil Lowry and a pen is given it was  awful decision but all ended well 

[RAPPO]

5 hours ago, Cornish Dave said:

It wasn’t a foul though the goalie had a stinker and tried the claim a cheap foul. Just like the red card it was last man no arguments 

What about the penalty not given at the end? 🤔

 

Dont think anyone blames the young Lino Footballchat. I did have a go myself standing behind him, which I’m not proud of asking him why he didn’t keep his flag up and call the ref over. He replied that he actually gave the penalty but the ref waived him away so that was the end of it. A fair comment I thought so I apologised. 👍👏🏼

[Footy follower]

Penryn v wendron

Decision 1........correct  decision but 9 times out of 10 it wdve been dissalowed for a "foul" on the keeper

Decision 2..correct decision.. Very reckless challenge by keeper as no attempt for ball and cdve caused serious injury(although that wasn't the aim) 

 

Decision 3..wrong decision.. Clear penalty

[Cornish Dave]

5 hours ago, RAPPO said:

What about the penalty not given at the end? 🤔

 

Dont think anyone blames the young Lino Footballchat. I did have a go myself standing behind him, which I’m not proud of asking him why he didn’t keep his flag up and call the ref over. He replied that he actually gave the penalty but the ref waived him away so that was the end of it. A fair comment I thought so I apologised. 👍👏🏼

Yes the penalty at the end is a penalty not saying it isn’t, but the red card and the other goal were correct decisions👍 Also the penryn manager will get himself into trouble if he is going to gob off at officials all game 

[WendronOfficial]

Think in honesty we got out of jail with it, I also think that it was doubly infuriating for Harry and Penryn given they had a controversial pen given against them on Saturday by all accounts - I’m sure that these will even out as they tend to over the course of the season. 
Rowan is a top Cornish ref too - he’s already achieved lots in the game and I’m sure he will continue to go onto bigger things, he reffed and managed the game well overall in my eyes. I think we all know it was the wrong decision, and he probably does too but he shouldn’t be chastised for it in some ways I’ve seen here and on Twitter. We are all guilty of making mistakes on the pitch. Some players on both sides missed some great chances themselves. 
 

Both sides have good fixtures to look forward to on Saturday as they both host prestigious sides at this level. 

[Martin Eddy]

9 hours ago, SCFC said:

 

totally agree with you both. I wouldn't pin it on the lino, just thought he could have been a bit more assertive. Even if the ref has told him to leave free kicks etc to him, for the benefit of the game, if you 100% believe he is wrong, would you not want to help? maybe thats just my personal opinion.

A chat at least would have been good, would at least help us spectators out, rather than it appearing the ref has given the decision himself from miles away.

 

It does the beg the question, whats the point in having paid linesman if they arent going to be used? 

Wether you believe he is right or wrong his word is final because as the referee he is in charge and you are part of his team. And how would it look if that team are arguing. It would be the same if two team mates argue, what would everyone say to them ?
 

[justanopinion]

It's a pity that we are seeing so much increased criticism of refs in recent posts. But it is a fact and coming from respected posters that have significant experience in the game. I'm not surprised having seen the quality in decline for a number years. I just wonder if refs and CFA officials read these posts? The penalty that was not given last night at Penryn - I just wonder if the ref today contacted the young lino to offer his apologies. He should have! None of us want to read these negative posts and you will not from the better ones that go unnoticed during a game. Criticising refs is not ideal but something is not quite right in the game where quality is falling year on year. Quite simply, players, managers, spectators do not post negative comments about the guys who make the game look simple and get most decisions correct.

[St Darren]

Referees are open to criticism as much as players. Let's remember they've passed a qualification to get to where they are, they have been promoted based on performances and they get paid to do the job.

Yes, they'll get things wrong, but don't blame people for criticising their performances. 

[justanopinion]

First para agreed. Not sure what you mean in second sentence, I'm certainly not blaming people for criticising their performance.

[St Darren]

11 minutes ago, justanopinion said:

First para agreed. Not sure what you mean in second sentence, I'm certainly not blaming people for criticising their performance.

It was a general statement really. 

[Dave Bartlam]

Trust me... If a referee gets a decision wrong and there is footage to back it up... No-one can be more critical of that referee than the ref himself!

Refs don't go out there to make mistakes, absolutely no chance. But it happens. It's unfortunate, but it happens.

Rowan has watched this video and it will absolutely make him a better referee.  There will be lessons learnt here and he will absolutely take them on board and apply them.

 

[TheolderIgetthebetterIwas]

At the end of the day we don't see what the referee see's, his/her view is different from ours, we are not standing where they are.

This sort of debate is what brought about VAR, the ruination of football for me, it is a spontaneous game with spontaneous decisions given from where THEY are standing, rightly or wrongly we have to accept the decision.

I didn't agree with some of the decisions, and the referee may well have given the push on our keeper, and the penalty shout, but he would have to have been standing next to me to see what I saw.

So I'll take it on the chin and wait for our turn to have the rub of the green later in the season, and no doubt it will happen. 

[SCFC]

Its great having the video footage for us all to review and have our say. Isnt that what the forum is for? Some agree, some disagree, some with rose tinted glasses, but thats what football is all about, opinions. I havent seen a single comment on here slating the ref, nothing about him being useless etc, as we all know he's a decent ref (Rowan Clark, must be around 23 years of age, reffed a much higher standard and is a cracking ref). 

Can only imagine he's seen something at the time that made him think it wasnt a penalty, but as said above, we all make mistakes and i'm sure he'd be the first to say he made a mistake there.

Certainly does even itself out over the course of the year, no doubt Penryn will get a couple of soft penalties/free kicks that lead to goals in their favour, or maybe a stonewall penalty against them denied. I can see how that will be hard to see though, having had a bad run of luck on Saturday and midweek but it will happen